Skip to main content

“Why is this happening to us?” (1919): Social Unrest and Mennonite Wealth

Stable political arrangements are rarely permanent and can unravel rapidly—and they did for tens of thousands of Mennonites a century ago in the Russian Empire. Not a few asked: “Why is this happening to us?”

Russia was a multicultural colonial empire with sense of a manifest destiny, a long history of serfdom and displacement of non-settler populations, and a yawning disparity of wealth.

A few hundred Mennonite owners of sprawling estates with extensive landholdings suffered most severely in the first period of lawlessness, chaos and revolution in Ukraine.

During a period of civil war in 1919 when the villages in the Mennonite Molotschna colony were largely under White Army protection, Kornelius Bergmann, a teacher and Mennonite Brethren minister, addressed the question everyone was asking, “Why is this happening to us?”

Bergmann wrote using the pseudonym "C. Orosander"—in order to speak freely (note 1).

He began by admonishing his fellow clergy for general failure of office. “They are the embodied conscience of the people,” but over decades, inner and intra-church conflict, impatience, malice, clerical domination and posturing before state officials defined the sad history of Mennonite church presence in Russia.

Moreover, Bergmann opined that most congregational members were too lazy to think, too cheap and indifferent to questions of church, mission and theological education—which all served to create the conditions for decline and unfaithfulness.

But Bergmann saved his most stinging barbs for the formerly wealthy—the estate owners.

Without question they had “suffered the most—economically, physically and certainly also morally … a large number were murdered, while the rest have moved into our [colony] villages and towns, some in comparatively humble accommodations,” Bergmann recognized.

Notably despite the “general misfortune of this class, there appears to be very little sympathy [from other Mennonites] or pity for these unfortunate ones” in the colony.

Rather the author observed there was a certain “Schadenfreude,” “indifference,” and even “hostility” towards these fellow Mennonites who now seek refuge in the colony. He granted that “envy” and “resentment” are two of the greatest vices among less-wealthy Mennonites, but nevertheless, the estate owners—or “steppe kings”—are solely responsible for this kind of reception.

First—as a teacher—he addressed the abysmal attitude towards education that the formerly wealthy have displayed, not only as patrons for those deserving scholarships, but also towards their own children of both sexes. "What percentage from their own offspring have completed high school, let alone university—especially the females," he asks rhetorically (knowing the percentages are small)?

Bergmann contrasted them with the wealthier classes in Germany who had taken on educational equality for girls in higher schools and university as a priority. But for wealthy Mennonites this has been “unnecessary.” “Learning takes effort, and until now they could go anywhere and do what they desired with empty heads, as long as their pockets were full.” Is it unfair to say they “lack the thirst for knowledge,” he asked?

Lives marked by “alcohol consumption and especially inter-marriage” amongst other vices had made it difficult for the children of these “plutocrats” to advance academically. In addition, they brought a “trained, deeply rooted aversion to any strenuous activity,” which had rendered a significant portion of this class of Mennonites “mentally inferior,” he argued.

The older teens play cards and go on their hunting expeditions, and maidens “eat, drink, dance and flirt with their cousins without any higher ideals of life, until they finally hook up with one of them and then as a couple they continue to live lives that are equally worthless for God and for humanity.” [NB: marriage with close relatives was practiced in order to concentrate wealth].

Of course, he noted, “there are numerous and notable exceptions,” but as a rule this class has “almost never made the interests of the whole [Mennonite peoplehood] their own.” So it is no wonder that now “so few tears flow in our villages” for the empty-handed estate owners.

Again, there were exceptions, but overall the support of Mennonite charitable institutions by Mennonite estate owners was “weak” at best. Bergmann traced the problem back to how these children were raised. “Without having learned the basics of filial-piety” a “caste spirit” developed “that was strictly contrary to our brotherly democratic principle of equality, which simply made them incapable of adapting to other people.” They “did not even want to pay their share of the [Alternative Service] barracks tax while, on the other hand, they generally spared no money to somehow free their sons from the barracks!”

The primary concern of estate owners has always been around land speculation, Bergmann lamented. Their appetite for land has been “insatiable ... the more he has, the more he wants.” “The thought that one’s greed for more land could possibly arouse the envy of the poor seems to have occurred only to a very few. If only they had thought not only of themselves, and had not just stood up for their own interests alone with so much energy! The servants on the estates—and especially the Russian [Ukrainian] seasonal workers—were nothing but poorly paid and very often poorly fed workhorses.”

The author as teacher and minister witnessed this even among the “most pious” estate families. “When times were good they did not make the things of God and of their people their own. And now when times are evil, it is not surprising that neither God nor their people make the cause of the former estate owners their own. As you sow, so shall you reap.”

These are harsh judgments and harsh and too broad. But the class distinctions identified by Bergmann were real, as Henry Goertz painfully recalled 57 years later in a fascinating, wide-ranging interview (audio; note 2).

Goertz’s Molotschna family had been poor, he notes. “Everyone wanted to know whose son you were,” and you were treated accordingly he said. Not only the wealthy Mennonite farmer, but also the Russian [Ukrainian] neighbour knew his economic background; the latter even approached him to join Makhno [Ukrainian anarchist leader]! While Goertz did not join Makhno (he did not hate the rich, because of the way he was brought up, he said), but notes that some Mennonites did.

Goertz volunteered for the Selbstschutz armed Mennonite self-defence, yet decades later still remembered how the same wealthy land owner who treated him poorly not only expected Selbstschutz assistance, but also paid to keep his own sons from Selbstschutz service.

Some two years later (1922), the former estate owners were “scattered in various Molotschna villages, but not all were well-received," as American Mennonite Relief director C. E. Krehbiel observed (note 3; beginnings of MCC). By 1924 in one of the two Molotschna districts (Gnadenfeld), for example, twenty-seven villages were housing 1,800 Mennonite refugees in sheds, barns, cellars, and extra spaces in homes, while another 362 people were completely homeless and living in earthen huts. The norm was two to three, but often five families per house, and most of the refugees were without bedding, soap, or change of clothes (note 4).

The former estate owners were amongst the first chosen for immigration to Canada because of their precarious lot. Immigration leader B.B. Janz could persuade Soviet Authorities that a limited group emigration of 3,000 would be advantageous, especially the formerly wealthy farmers (kulaks) and “starving people whose absence might substantially benefit the colonies and enable economic reconstruction to begin” (note 5).

Many of prejudices and marriage expectations would continue in Canada for a generation.

            ---Arnold Neufeldt-Fast

---Notes---

Photos are randomly chosen from the page https://chortitza.org/FB/bguts.html, "Bilder und Fotos mennonitische Gutbesitzer und Guts (Chutors) in Russland."

Note 1: See Kornelius P. Bergmann (pseud. C. Orosander). “Warum geschieht uns solches?,” Part I, Friedensstimme 17 no. 42 (December 14, 1919), 1–2, https://chortitza.org/pdf/pletk99.pdf; Part II, 17, no. 43 (December 21, 1919), 1–2, https://chortitza.org/pdf/pletk100.pdf. Similarly, cf. previous post for November 1919 editorial by Abraham Kröker (forthcoming).

Note 2: Henry Paetkau, interviewer, “Tape #4 Interview with Henry Goertz,” July 1976, sound recording. Russian-Mennonite immigrants of the 1920’s (Niagara Peninsula), edited by E. Baar, Brock University, St. Catharines, ON, http://hdl.handle.net/10464/13713.

Note 3: Example of Schönfeld refugees, in C. E. Krehbiel Journal, May 30, 1922; Mennonite Library and Archives, Bethel College, Newton, KS, https://mla.bethelks.edu/archives/ms_11/.

Note 4: N. Rempel and A. Brauer, “Report Regarding the Situation of the Refugees in the Gnadenfeld District” (Kharkov, July 22, 1924),” in The Mennonites in Russia from 1917 to 1930. Selected Documents, ed. John B. Toews (Winnipeg, MB: Christian, 1975), 55f.; John B. Toews, Lost Fatherland (Scottdale, PA: Herald, 1977), 170, https://archive.org/details/lostfatherlandst0000toew.

In the years before the war Mennonite farms typically employed three or four domestic servants (Dienstbote) and “almost exclusively Russian,” according to Muntau farmer and Halbstadt elder Heinrich P. Unruh (Heinrich P. Unruh to Helena Unruh Richert Balzer, May 2, 1914, 2, letter, from Mennonite Library and Archives-Bethel College, https://mla.bethelks.edu/archives/mf_chr_34/15.jpg). H. P. Unruh employed “from October 1 to May 9, two males (three in spring) and one female, and together they receive a salary of 500 to 550 rubles.”

Note 5: Toews, Lost Fatherland, 132f.; 140. Cf. “Minutes of the Union Board Meeting, May 7–8, 1924” also (Resolution of the Verband on emigration, Feb. 26–28, 1925) in Union of Citizens of Dutch Lineage in Ukraine (1922–1927): Mennonite and Soviet Documents, translated by J. B. Toews, O. Shmakina, and W. Regehr (Fresno, CA: Center for Mennonite Brethren Studies, 2011), 215f.; 220f., https://archive.org/details/unionofcitizenso0000unse.

For further reading, see James Urry, "Through the Eye of a Needle: Wealth and the Mennonite Experience in Imperial Russia," Journal of Mennonite Studies 3 (1985), 7-35. https://jms.uwinnipeg.ca/index.php/jms/article/view/42/42.





Print Friendly and PDF

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Fraktur (or Gothic) font and Kurrent- (or Sütterlin) handwriting: Nazi ban, 1941

In the middle of the war on January 1, 1942, the Winnipeg-based Mennonitische Rundschau published a new issue without the familiar Fraktur script masthead ( note 1 ). One might speculate on the reasons, but a year earlier Hitler banned the use of the font in the Reich . The Rundschau did not exactly follow all orders from Berlin—the rest of the paper was in Fraktur (sometimes referred to as "Gothic"); when the war ended in 1945, the Rundschau reintroduced the Fraktur font for its masthead. It wasn’t until the 1960s that an issue might have a page or title here or there with the “normal” or Latin font, even though post-war Germany was no longer using Fraktur . By 1973 only the Rundschau masthead is left in Fraktur , and that is only removed in December 1992. Attached is a copy of Nazi Party Secretary Martin Bormann's official letter dated January 3, 1941, which prohibited the use of Fraktur fonts "by order of the Führer. " Why? It was a Jewish invention, apparent...

The Jewish Colony (Judenplan) and its Mennonite Agriculturalists

Both Jews and Mennonites in Russia were dependent on separation, distinct external appearance, unique dialect, inner group cohesion, international familial networks, self-governing institutions, a sojourner mentality, sense of divine mission, and a view of the other as unclean or dangerous. Each had its distinct legal privileges, restrictions, and duties under the Tsar, and each looked out for their own. For both, moderation, spiritual values, family, learning and success were important, and their related dialects made communication possible. But the traditional occupation of eastern European Jews was as “middlemen” between the “overwhelmingly agricultural Christian population and various urban markets,” as peddlers, shopkeepers and suppliers of goods ( note 1 ). Jews were forbidden to stay for longer periods in German colonies or to erect houses or shops there. “If they try to stay, they are to be reported immediately. If they are not, the German mayor will be held responsible” ( no...

What is the Church to Say? Letter 4 (of 4) to American Mennonite Friends

Irony is used in this post to provoke and invite critical thought; the historical research on the Mennonite experience is accurate and carefully considered. ~ANF Preparing for your next AGM: Mennonite Congregations and Deportations Many U.S. Mennonite pastors voted for Donald Trump, whose signature promise was an immediate start to “the largest deportation operation in American history.” Confirmed this week, President Trump will declare a national emergency and deploy military assets to carry this out. The timing is ideal; in January many Mennonite congregations have their Annual General Meeting (AGM) with opportunity to review and update the bylaws of their constitution. Need help? We have related examples from our tradition, which I offer as a template, together with a few red flags. First, your congregational by-laws.  It is unlikely you have undocumented immigrants in your congregation, but you should flag this. Model: Gustav Reimer, a deacon and notary public from the ...

What is the Church to Say? Letter 1 (of 4) to American Mennonite Friends

Irony is used in this post to provoke and invite critical thought; the historical research on the Mennonite experience is accuarte and carefully considered. ~ANF American Mennonite leaders who supported Trump will be responding to the election results in the near future. Sometimes a template or sample conference address helps to formulate one’s own text. To that end I offer the following. When Hitler came to power in 1933, Mennonites in Germany sent official greetings by telegram: “The Conference of the East and West Prussian Mennonites meeting today at Tiegenhagen in the Free City of Danzig are deeply grateful for the tremendous uprising ( Erhebung ) that God has given our people ( Volk ) through the vigor and action of [unclear], and promise our cooperation in the construction of our Fatherland, true to the Gospel motto of [our founder Menno Simons], ‘For no one can lay any foundation other than the one already laid, which is Jesus Christ.’” ( Note 1 ) Hitler responded in a letter...

Sesquicentennial: Proclamation of Universal Military Service Manifesto, January 1, 1874

One-hundred-and-fifty years ago Tsar Alexander II proclaimed a new universal military service requirement into law, which—despite the promises of his predecesors—included Russia’s Mennonites. This act fundamentally changed the course of the Russian Mennonite story, and resulted in the emigration of some 17,000 Mennonites. The Russian government’s intentions in this regard were first reported in newspapers in November 1870 ( note 1 ) and later confirmed by Senator Evgenii von Hahn, former President of the Guardianship Committee ( note 2 ). Some Russian Mennonite leaders were soon corresponding with American counterparts on the possibility of mass migration ( note 3 ). Despite painful internal differences in the Mennonite community, between 1871 and Fall 1873 they put up a united front with five joint delegations to St. Petersburg and Yalta to petition for a Mennonite exemption. While the delegations were well received and some options could be discussed with ministers of the Crown, ...

Catherine the Great’s 1763 Manifesto

“We must swarm our vast wastelands with people. I do not think that in order to achieve this it would be useful to compel our non-Christians to accept our faith--polygamy for example, is even more useful for the multiplication of the population. … "Russia does not have enough inhabitants, …but still possesses a large expanse of land, which is neither inhabited nor cultivated. … The fields that could nourish the whole nation, barely feeds one family..." – Catherine II (Note 1 ) “We perceive, among other things, that a considerable number of regions are still uncultivated which could easily and advantageously be made available for productive use of population and settlement. Most of the lands hold hidden in their depth an inexhaustible wealth of all kinds of precious ores and metals, and because they are well provided with forests, rivers and lakes, and located close to the sea for purpose of trade, they are also most convenient for the development and growth of many kinds ...

What is the Church to Say? Letter 2 of 4 to American Mennonite Friends

Irony is used in this post to provoke and invite critical thought; the historical research on the Mennonite experience is accurate and carefully considered. ~ANF In a few short months the American government will start to fulfill its campaign promises to round up and deport undocumented immigrants. The responsible cabinet members have already been appointed. By early Spring 2025, Mennonite pastors/leaders who supported Trump will need to speak to and address the matter in their congregations. It will be difficult to find words. How might they prepare? Sometimes a template from the past is helpful. To that end, I offer my summary of a text by retired Mennonite pastor and conference leader Gustav Kraemer. (There is a nice entry on him in the Mennonite Encyclopedia,  GAMEO ). My summary is faithful to the German original, 1938. With only a few minor changes, it could be useful for the coming year. Adaptations are mostly in square brackets, with the key at the bottom of the post. ...

The Flight to Moscow 1929

In 1926, my grandfather’s sister Justina Fast (b. 1896) and her husband Peter Görzen moved from Krassikow, Neu Samara (Soviet Union) to village no. 5 Dejewka, Orenburg. “We thought we would live our lives here with our children secure in the hands of God. But the times were becoming turbulent,” Justina recalled. In May 1929 they travelled back to Krassikow for Pentecost to visit with her mother, brothers and their families. But when they returned to their home, she writes, “… a large quota of grain was demanded of us. But we had nothing, and the harvest was not yet in. Then we heard that many were planning to move to Canada, including my three siblings with my mother, and my husband's three sisters too. My husband decided to go to Moscow first to see if it was possible and what was required for emigration. We made the decision to leave when the harvest was complete. At that time so many people were leaving [for Moscow], and early in September we sold everything we had. Only the b...

What is the Church to Say? Letter 3 (of 4) to American Mennonite Friends

Irony is used in this post to provoke and invite critical thought; the historical research on the Mennonite experience is accurate and carefully considered. ~ANF Mennonite endorsement Trump the man No one denies the moral flaws of Donald Trump, least of all Trump himself. In these next months Mennonite pastors who supported Trump will have many opportunities to restate to their congregation and their children why someone like Trump won their support. It may be obvious, but the words can be difficult to find. To help, I offer examples from Mennonite history with statements from one our strongest leaders of the past century, Prof. Benjamin H. Unruh (see the nice Mennonite Encyclopedia article on him, GAMEO ). I have substituted only a few words, indicated by square brackets to help with the adaptation. The [MAGA] movement is like the early Anabaptist movement!  In the change of government in 1933, Unruh saw in the [MAGA] movement “things breaking forth which our forefathe...

1929 Flight of Mennonites to Moscow and Reception in Germany

At the core of the attached video are some thirty photos of Mennonite refugees arriving from Moscow in 1929 which are new archival finds. While some 13,000 had gathered in outskirts of Moscow, with many more attempting the same journey, the Soviet Union only released 3,885 Mennonite "German farmers," together with 1,260 Lutherans, 468 Catholics, 51 Baptists, and 7 Adventists. Some of new photographs are from the first group of 323 refugees who left Moscow on October 29, arriving in Kiel on November 3, 1929. A second group of photos are from the so-called “Swinemünde group,” which left Moscow only a day later. This group however could not be accommodated in the first transport and departed from a different station on October 31. They were however held up in Leningrad for one month as intense diplomatic negotiations between the Soviet Union, Germany and also Canada took place. This second group arrived at the Prussian sea port of Swinemünde on December 2. In the next ten ...